S and X-band rhoHV observations in hail: 3 August 2013


Jump to: navigation, search

Author: P. C. Kennedy

Web 3aug2013 2237 VCHILL NWS Z anot.png

An intense reflectivity core produced hailstones that punctured a plastic yard fence gate at the indicated location in southwestern Greeley on 3 August 2013. Plots of the CSU-CHILL S and X-band $ \rho_{HV} $ fields observed around the time of this hail damage have been prepared.



During the late afternoon hours of Saturday, 3 August 2013, severe thunderstorm activity affected several locations in northeastern Colorado. The CSU-CHILL radar was primarily collecting low elevation angle PPI sector scans to support a rain mapping project. These scans captured a damaging hailstorm that moved across the southern portions Greeley. The following two photographs show holes that the hailstone impacts caused in the yard gate of a house located in southwestern Greeley. A few of the stones passed completely though both of the plastic faces of the gate. The hole sizes indicate that the hailstones were approximately 2 to 3 cm in diameter (roughly 1 inch). Depending upon their surface water coating thickness, hailstones larger than ~ 1 to 1.5 cm in diameter will begin to cause detectable Mie scattering effects at X-band (Jameson and Srivastava, JAM 1978, p1694-1703).

Gate w house 2kw.jpg

Gate close up 2kw.jpg

S-band hail indications

The following plot shows the S-band (3 GHz) CSU-CHILL reflectivity field at 1.5 deg elevation angle as the storm's >65 dBZ reflectivity core was just starting to reach the location of the gate. To facilitate comparisons of the fields, both the S and X-band data have been interpolated by the NCAR SPRINT program to a common set of 0.25 km mesh Cartesian grid points on the original PPI scan surfaces.

Web 3aug2013 S Zovly anot.png

The corresponding S-band differential reflectivity ($ Z_{dr} $) field is shown in the next plot. For reference, an overlay of the 55 and 65 dBZ reflectivity contour lines has been added. Relative to the surrounding lower reflectivity areas, the $ Z_{dr} $ values in the echo cores are reduced in magnitude. Since $ Z_{dr} $ remained positive, the precipitation in the echo cores probably consisted of a mixture of oblate hydrometeors (large rain drops and melting ice particles with a thick water coating) and larger diameter, quasi-spherical / tumbling hailstones. Due to the generally west to east echo motions, the high reflectivity / low $ Z_{dr} $ indications of hail in the echo core probably began to reach the location of the damaged gate within ~2 minutes of this PPI scan time.

Web 3aug2013 S Zovly Zdr anot.png

$ \rho_{HV} $ data at S and X-bands

The following two plots show the co-polar H,V correlation ($ \rho_{HV} $) fields observed at S and X-bands. To eliminate noise contamination, a +5 dB SNR threshold was applied to the X-band $ \rho_{HV} $ data. To focus attention on the probable hail-containing areas, both plots have also been thresholded at the 55 dBZ S-band reflectivity level. The S-band data shows a general correlation reduction to levels of ~ 0.9 in the immediate vicinity of the damaged gate. Even lower S-Band correlations (~ 0.83) were found in the reflectivity gradient region along the southeastern edge of the plotted echo.

Web 3aug2013 S RH10 anot.png

The next plot shows the corresponding X-band $ \rho_{HV} $ data. The X-band $ \rho_{HV} $ levels are considerably lower than the S-band values (~0.73 vs. ~0.85 - 0.90) in the echo core region to the southeast of the gate damage location. The SNR in this region exceeds +30 dB, so $ \rho_{HV} $ lowering due to noise is insignificant. This increased $ \rho_{HV} $ reduction may have resulted from the Mie scattering effects at X-band due to the ~ 2cm diameter hailstones. (The Mie scattering effects at S-band would be less due to the longer wavelength.) In some portions of the southeastern, high gradient edge of the plotted echo, the X-band correlations are higher than the S-band values. This may be the result of the larger S-band pulse volume size: 150m in range and 1.0 deg in azimuth vs. the X-band's 75m in range and 0.3 deg in azimuth.

Web 3aug2013 X RH10 anot V2.png


The hailstone diameters documented at one location in the 3 August 2013 Greeley hailstorm are consistent with the expectation of preferentially larger Mie scattering effects at X-band vs. S-band. Considerably more work is needed to confirm these preliminary results.